I don’t know what is sadder, Thomas Coughlan’s hysterical rantings at Willie Jackson or Melissa Lee’s hysterical rantings at Willie Jackson or Glenn McConnell’s hysterical rantings on Willie Jackson.
I thought Willie’s interview was funny, he answered the questions and he explained what the RNZ/TVNZ merger was all about and he was giving Jack a bit of mischievous stick while he was doing it. I also thought Jack was an amazing interviewer and I also thought Grant did a bloody good interview too!
Coughlan, who I had an enormous amount of time for as a journalist on any other day, clearly took offence at Willie’s style and went on a triggered snowflake kamikaze attack on Willie Jackson while smearing him with a despicable character assassination.
Like an anti vaxer fanatic convinced the vaccine has a micro chip in it, Coughlan argues that Willie actually wants to take over RNZ/TVNZ and run it as his own propaganda channel – which is a deplorable insinuation!
Willie Jackson, the youngest meat workers union president in NZ history, has always sided with the workers over the bosses! He has always sided with independent media! He has always sided with the journalists over the managers! He has always sided with free media!
To pretend as Coughlan has that Willie actually intends to make ANZPM his own media instrument which is beholden to him is such a lie and grasping attempt at editorial clickbait it is a stain on Coughlan’s reputation!
Of course NZME is going to attack a new ANZPM and that is all Coughlan is really channeling here, his own companies self interest. It’s right wing corporate media trying to crap on public broadcasting NZME will have to compete against!
This despite Willie starting legislation that will allow mainstream media to get revenue from Facebook and Google!
Melissa Lee who is facing Simon Bridges as the new Chair is doing everything she can to keep shitting on public broadcasting in case Cabinet gives it to Bridges which will rob her of any target so anything she has to say on the merger is politicking…
National’s broadcasting spokesperson Melissa Lee described Jackson’s interview this morning as a “train wreck”.
“The way he talked on Q + A is a clear sign he intends on interfering with the culture, operations and decisions of the new entity while having political influence over it,” Lee said.
This is the same smear Coughlan is trying on. The idea that Willie has structured the merger for him to have direct editorial control over the entire organisation is a dangerous fantasy that Lee and Coughlan are running in their joint effort to discredit Public Broadcasting.
As for Glenn McConnell, (Stuffs more masculine version of Coughlan), he claims Willie can’t explain why a merger is needed.
Let me spell it out for Glenn, Fuck Boy Island!
The response by TVNZ to Fuck Boy Island proves why they must be merged with RNZ!
Their answer has been to edit out one of the contestants who turned out to be an actual Fuck Boy…
Fuckboy Island contestant edited out after suffocation charge revealed
A contestant on controversial reality TV series Fboy Island is being edited out of the show after it was revealed he was charged last year with suffocating a drunk and vulnerable teenager in his home.
…note that their response isn’t, ‘we should never have commissioned a show called Fuck Boy Island because we are the public broadcaster’, oh no, they are still going ahead with Fuck Boy Island, they’ll just edit out the one accused of strangling a drunk woman.
TVNZ are a ratings chasing addict who have utterly shat upon their Public Broadcaster responsibilities here, THIS is why we need a RNZ/TVNZ merger!
The extraordinarily gross Fuck Boy Island commissioned by TVNZ shows why the RNZ/TVNZ merger must happen, because TVNZ thinks Fuck Boy Island is public broadcasting!
RNZ would never have allowed Fuck Boy Island to occur.
Can you imagine Kim Hill judging Fuck Boy Island?
How about Ethical Slut Island?
This isn’t Public Broadcasting that uplifts or builds the people or audiences involved, it demeans. I’m no prude, if a private company wanted Fuck Boy Island, knock yourself out, go for it, but on the Public Broadcaster?
We saw on the lawns of Parliament what confused and frightened citizens led by Social media disinformation hate algorithms can cause, we need a powerful Public Broadcasting asset to combat that madness or our Democracy will be lost.
We need this public broadcasting merger and Fuck Boy Island proves why.
Framing Willie as a power mad Māori who is trying to take over RNZ/TVNZ and control it editorially while Fuck Boy Island is out there is ugly media politics.
Increasingly having independent opinion in a mainstream media environment which mostly echo one another has become more important than ever, so if you value having an independent voice – please donate here.
If you can’t contribute but want to help, please always feel free to share our blogs on social media
Bring on Ethical Slut Island!
Even Jacinda agreed the interview had Willie saying some wrong thinks which she repremined for .I bet he will be moved on as will Mahuta at the next shuffle which will upset the Maori. She should get ride of Kelvin but that would be a step to far
No. That would be the end of this government. Mahuta and Jackson would not accept that. Ardern will go first.
Without Ardern Mahuta and Willie are in the opposition benches.
Who needs who?
I doubt there was any reprimand. They own her!
Of course there wasn’t.
Martyn’s faith in state-run broadcasting is beyond explanation. Or logic.
Your faith in commercial entities to deliver programming that isnt shit is repulsive.
From 1975 to 1989, NZ had the best TV content in the world. Documentaries, current affairs, variety shows, light entertainment, you name it we had it. Then people like you decided that it needed to make a ‘profit’ and just put wall to wall reality TV on instead.
“Best content in the world”
You know this how? Were you watching everything else everywhere, Millsy?
kindly name a COUNTRY WHERE PRIVATE BROADCASTING IS BETTER? just one ada
She’s too busy washing her bloomers @ Garg – or rather putting them in the latest whiteware where she’s dialled ‘set and forget’ so she’s got time to look over the books.
(We need folk like it to ridicule and have a laugh. I’m really concerned though about her lumbago and her ability to continue to access adequate private healthcare – let alone state provided services, such as transport, fire and emergency services and the like )
Next time I hop on a bus that hasn’t been cancelled, I’ll defer to her entitlements because it’s considerably more needy than mine – even though it’s quite happy to flick between those services provided by the “state”, and those it’s chosen to subscribe to.
It must be a real bitch to be hitched to – if indeed it’s hitched
You resort to insults because you don’t have an argument to make.
Once was Tim, your misogynistic bent is on full show
What is “better” is subjective, Gargarin.
It is the height of arrogance for a cultural or intellectual elite to impose their tastes and preferences on what gets government subsidised production and then broadcast.
as is your estimation of ‘worse’ ada you don’t know what I watch/stream so the cultural elite thing falls on it’s face..
and it sounds like you just want to impose your preferences on NZ
Christ! You sound like Bill Ralston. He used to moan about “state tv” in the days of his Ralston Group (which wasn’t all that great), but who was then quite happy to go on later to run it when the clowns took over.
“Martyn’s faith in state-run broadcasting is beyond explanation. Or logic:
“STATE TV” or “STATE RADIO” is the usual descriptor used to stifle the public voice and means of expression.
I guess we could go back to soap boxes outside the local Town Hall and buskers and various artists crowding each other out. I’d vote for you @ fucking Ada to lead the way.
Martyn’s faith in PUBLIC broadcasting is legitimate – provided it’s representative and provides a voice to its public.
But Public broadcasting is never representative, is it?
It always represents what a government-appointed cultural or intellectual elite decides should be shown or listened to by the plebs. Sometimes the programs shown are popular, but often not and only survive on air because of other government policy goals.
Ada. I suggest that a government whose idea of a diplomat is Trevor Mallard can hardly be described as a cultural or intellectual elite.
Loved that GA.
This Melissa Lee: https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/mp-motorway-would-keep-south-auckland-criminals-out/ECNWU6W5J3TZBOARN2KZKFA5ZE/
Fuck Boy Island is one of the reasons we should disband TVNZ. Give their assets to RNZ maybe, but there’s nothing redeemable in TVNZ to merge.
As for nefarious editorial control: if not Willie then someone else. In fact is there any way to prevent it, in any media? Prevent from govt would mean destroying public media, and disbanding the security services and police to prevent meddling in private. And you’re still left with private media and all the wealthy and powerful people in the world.
Look at TVNZ. It is wall to wall reality TV and wall to wall ads. Unacceptable. The case for the merger is right there
The amusing thing about this whole argument is it resembles a couple of Neanderthals arguing over who gets to kill and eat the last Wolly Mammoth alive.
MSM is a SUNSET INDUSTRY. It is dead in 10 years. People aren’t leaving it because of Qanon or Trump or vaccine mandates – they are leaving the MSM because it is garbage and increasingly expensive to produce.
All future funding of the MSM by central Western governments is putting good money after bad.
It’s over. In the Grief cycle best to move onto acceptance.
TVNZ and RNZ could be redeemed if they had a code of conduct that required strict political neutrality. But that’s never going to happen under this government – possibly not under any government. Requiring an editorial line consistent with the revisionist Treaty of Waitangi is NOT political neutrality – journalists and interviewees should be free to question contemporary political orthodoxies.
Maybe although likely just delaying the inevitable. People don’t watch TV when the streaming options are better and social media (such as this) presents more insightful political commentary.
The beauty of course is most in the MSM are patently unsuitable for any other role therefore have written their own suicide note with their behavior over the past decade.
Happy days indeed.
100% Pope
Pope do you ACTUALLY listen to the Radio NZ or watch TVNZ. If you do you must see the right wing bias especially on the news . Jessica Mutch Mackay publicly stating on a radio NZ political round up “ how they are encouraging Luxon to have more photo opportunities so that people get to know him better “ The right are up in arms because everything Willi Jackson said was true and they will all get found out and they know it.
The Tories want to take over TVNZ & RNZ then they will have total control of media in NZ. All that free Natz party political broadcasting they get now, hard right political polls, no policies, plenty of ammo from labour and they still wont win the elections with hopeless performers like Lxon and Willis, Goldsmith, Mitchell, Reti.
I can’t understand why TVNZ + has better shows, content that have never been on TV . Who is funding this because not many adverts either.
Well said Pope.
agree pope you could also addthe balance (by law) that ronnie raygun ditched in the states, usuring in fox etc…
I see this piece from you Martyn has brought every bigot out to play in the comments section.
Funny how NZ politics always descends to bash the Māori.
It’s bloody depressing.
Ignatius for my part any faults of Willie is for what he says and the facts are he brings the race arguement into the equation. For to long he has said outrageous statements then hide behind his Maori personna to avoid any criticism.
I don’t own a TV, yet as far as I’m aware there are NO public access TV stations in NZ?
In parts of America I’ve been lead to believe you can just book a slot on public access TV and BOOM, you’re on television!
My point is; television access in NZ is both cost prohibitive and guarded by government gatekeepers.
If the government is willing to shovel $350+ million to merge the entrenched (and declining) RNZ with TVNZ, surely the public should have the ability to compete? Why shouldn’t The Working Group also be streamed live on a public access TV station?
The reality is television in NZ doesn’t allow for free speech, therefore it is a substandard medium for news and current affairs. As the government is funding this new entity, yet denies the citizenry access to a public access TV station.. there is NO credibility to be had.
If the public don’t have access to speak on medium (TV in this case), there obviously cannot be free speech on that medium.
Do I have a point, or am I missing something?
RNZ
“Royal Commission of Inquiry into Covid-19 pandemic response: What you need to know”
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/top/480144/royal-commission-of-inquiry-into-covid-19-pandemic-response-what-you-need-to-know
So, rnz’s telling me what I need to know is it.
What a waste of a Royal Commission of Inquiry just to pointlessly line a few pockets dissecting a neutered event that’s already heading into history.
What we really need a Royal Commission of Inquiry in to is our economy, our politics and the crooks who now make money from what were once our taxes-paid-for world class resources and assets.
Yes lets stream the Working Group on the Tele. Absolutely terrific as is your blog site Martyn
Willie is actually a free speech maverick, by introducing “useless Maori” into the political lexicon in this time of microaggression outrage, he managed to impress the supremacists while also undermining anti hate speech darling Jacinda Ardern, outraging human rights pearl clutcher Paul Hunt, confusing race relations commissar Meng Foon and caricaturing the indigenous community, all in one fell swoop. Slay my queen.